Kincardine Record
Banner Ad
Banner Ad

​Secord Monument showed that sometimes a man is honoured, respected in his own country

Letter to the EditorBy: Letter to the Editor  January 15, 2025
​Secord Monument showed that sometimes a man is honoured, respected in his own country
To the Editor:

How haunting for me it was, reading this article (below) about my great-uncle, Dr. Solomon Secord.

As you read and envision how he lanced the throat of a young child who was lying there dying with diphtheria, as a last effort, and sucked the infection out with his own lips to try and save the dying child.

And then you read the last paragraph, of the honour and accolades from the residents and the community of Kincardine. How they, fittingly, turned their memories of a local pioneering Canadian physician with the highest ideals and a servant of the sick and afflicted (and there were many such country doctors in those early days across Canada) into a tangible form of gratitude. Local residents and families donated their own money for a Canadian monument to "show that sometimes a man is honoured and must be respected in his own country."

And now, fast forward to the current mayor, deputy mayor and all those on the council who destroyed the Dr. Solomon Secord Monument.

The Secord Seven, who had no business making a decision like this in the first place, and even more importantly, completely disregarded the very wishes of the pioneers of the community and the majority of citizens who elected them.

Community residents whose families very likely contributed to this monument and, quite likely, families who might not even be here if it wasn't for Dr. Solomon Secord.

How could this council be so cruel?

Not even return my communication prior to the monument's destruction.

They should all take a walk in the snow and join our recently-resigned Canadian prime minister.

Then I will be pleased to offer to provide, in trust, to the community of Kincardine, another monument of the same.

Best regards,
David Secord
Calgary, Alberta



This article is from "The Kincardine Review," in 1964

Related Stories

No related stories.

Share

    Comments (10)

  1. Mary Gallant
    2025-01-15 23:01:34
    The Kincardine council should be ashamed of the treatment of Dr Secord, his monument , and to his family, and should replace the monument to a prominent position on Queen street
  2. Brian Grohs
    2025-01-16 04:43:51
    Makes you wonder will town folk 109 years from now remove and destroy Charlie Mann’s plaque when someone states they are offended by his heroic war actions. As a citizen of this town I can only offer my apologies to the Secord Family for the actions of our elected officials
  3. Marilyn ARscott
    2025-01-16 08:32:59
    Well the minority wins again. Trying to keep the Woke people happy. News flash! They will NEVER be happy.
  4. T.Hodgins
    2025-01-16 09:59:50
    The current council should replace the monument with their own money . The money should not have to come from the Secord Family . And there should be a public apology to the family and the residence of Kincardine and an explanation as to why the family was not given the courtesy of a reply regarding the Secord monument . Once again , I am so sorry this happened ...it should not have . Best regards...The Majority of Kincardine .
  5. Cheryl Nicholson
    2025-01-16 22:55:49
    When you destroy a part of Kincardine’s History. You begin to lose your town. The erasing of History is wrong on so many levels. My heart goes out to the Secord family. I came from one of the founding families of Port Elgin Watching this desecration of history was revolting.
  6. Ronny Smith
    2025-01-17 09:12:01
    I wonder how many months we have to go on with this before we put it to bed? Do I agree with the decision to remove the monument? No, I don't. But this is how municipal decisions get made. You agree sometimes, you disagree sometimes. But someone has to make a decision. Ever hear of the phrase too many cooks in the kitchen? If the people who are constantly dwelling on this used the energy that they spend ridiculing every single thing that happens in our community, and put that energy towards something positive, maybe we would have a stronger community. If we need a monument as a single passage to recognize our history, then we have bigger problems. I think everyone should take a breath of fresh air, get off of Facebook comments, go outside and enjoy the community we have. And if you are constantly feeling disgruntled with this community, please leave.
  7. Shirley Ross
    2025-01-17 11:54:00
    I too was shocked, saddened and disgusted with our council! Why did they feel they could erase history? When monument was erected I am sure people from the community donated to it just like our community center and yet our council felt they alone could destroy it. We will remember them!!!!!
  8. Glenn Hedley
    2025-01-18 06:03:01
    The editorial by David Secord was a beautiful bitter sweet wrttrn. article. If necessary I would be happy to to contribute money to replace the monument and locate it in the Park acrooss from the Old Town Hall.
  9. Dave Cuyler
    2025-01-16 12:08:16
    I to am upset with what we are calling a council in The Municipality of Kincardine. The leader of the "Secord Seven" was the first to speak and set the toneof the vote to destroy the monument comemorating Dr. Secord. He also did not return calls from family members about a solutionas to the placement of the monument which did not belong to Kincardine or did he answer the offer of a place to store it from the County of Bruce. My wife talked with our C.A.O. and was told that the family had been given enough time to contact the municipality as to thier wishes. There still had been no reply communication with the family. It is my opinion that the leader of council was on a mission to destroy this monument for the satisfaction of a few activists as seen on a break in the television broadcast of the meeting. If details are needed I have footage. He claims this was done for the whole community instead of catering to a few that disagreed. What they did was cater to a few that claimed to have all the information that proved the good doctor was not what he was portraid as. The information that they "exhausted" themselves researching left out all the parts proving them wrong. The two doing this research were also on amission in my opinion. I could go on picking these peoples actions apart but we would be here after the Kincardine Record has thier 50 th anniversary and I would be long gone. When I first became aware of this fiasco, I told the one councillor that showed common sense that I would oppose this and it only got more idiotic as time moved on. My great great grandfather came to Penetangore in 1850 and his name is Paddy Walker. My great great grandfather Cuyler arrived here in 1852. Between the two families there were twenty children so I'm sure some, if not all, used the good doctors service at some time. This whole situation has been brought about by a few people that have only been here for a short time, not knowing the complete history of the region, and trying to change what we as longtime residents have enjoyed for over a century. Even the socalled mayor is ignorant to the facts in this case. I grew up knowing his grandparents because they were my nieghbours and friends and i'm sure they would also be appalled at what took place. I feel sorry for the municipal employee that had to watch "Operation Secord" be carried out as it took all day to complete. Granite is tough stuff. Also he was only doing his job. I will quit now as I'm sure anyone reading this knows I'm upset. Thanks for your time, Dave Cuyler
  10. Barry Holt
    2025-01-16 12:21:57
    Counsel should own up to this bad decision and erect a monument of the same by the library. This would show respect to the Secord family and the majority of Kincardine inhabitants.

Leave a Comment

By submitting this form, I consent that my name (and email, if provided) will be published on kincardinerecord.com as part of this story.


Banner Ad
Banner Ad