Kincardine Record
Banner Ad
Banner Ad

Ask the Pharmacist

Ron and Marla ChapleauBy: Ron and Marla Chapleau  February 8, 2018
Ask the Pharmacist
Q: Perhaps next to lower back pain, the search for help in the treatment of a cough is the most frequently-asked question at many pharmacies.

Traditionally, pharmacists' treatment decisions have focussed on whether the cough is wet (i.e. bringing up phlegm from the chest) or dry (more of a hacking “bark”), as well as patient factors such as other conditions you may suffer from (particularly asthma or COPD) or work-related concerns (are you preparing food for others, do you speak for a living, do you spend time around those who are immune-suppressed).

A new look at the research has caused some health practitioners to question whether the type of cough is even remotely important, and raised questions about just how effective our traditional cough syrups really are. As far as they are concerned, the first question should be aimed at determining whether this is an acute cough (i.e. you’ve only been suffering from it recently) or a chronic one.

Acute coughs are defined as ones that have lasted less than three weeks (rather arbitrarily) and a chronic cough is one that has lasted longer than eight weeks (what we term those in between seems to be an open mystery).

Chronic cough may be a symptom of a respiratory disorder (i.e. asthma) or gastrointestinal disorder (such as gastroesophageal reflux disorder) and should always be assessed by your physician to rule out significant disease states. Acute cough is almost always caused by a viral upper respiratory tract infection and can be self-treated as long as you do not have any accompanying symptoms that might indicate you are suffering from a more dangerous infection such as pneumonia.

These “red flag” symptoms include localized chest pain, the coughing up of blood or pleuritic chest pain (this is described as pain upon breathing “in” that is felt in the chest and worsens when coughing, sneezing or moving around). Coughs associated with this, should be assessed promptly by a physician.

In all other cases, you are probably dealing with a virus which can be safely treated on your own. The usual course of these types of viruses is typically a couple of days of sneezing, runny nose and nasal congestion (with or without a headache) followed by a cough which usually begins on day two or three. Of all of these symptoms, it is the cough that proves to be most troublesome as it usually lasts much longer than the others, sometimes even up to 25 days.

Experts feel that regardless of whether coughs are wet, dry, chesty or tickly, they are all caused by the same mechanism and, hence, should be treated in the same way. The virus causes the airways to become inflamed which, in turn, causes their sensory nerves to become hypersensitive (i.e. overly sensitive) so that even mild stimulation (such as a change in temperature when you go outdoors) causes the nerves to “fire,” leading to not only the cough reflex but also some of the other symptoms we may be feeling such as a sore or tickly throat.

This cough, in turn, allows the virus to be spread to others in our vicinity as they are exposed to the droplets that inevitably come out of our mouth when we don’t cover it sufficiently with a mask or at the very least our hands.

Treatment is, therefore, aimed at reducing this cough sensitivity which will allow the affected person to feel and sleep better while helping to protect the people who live/work around them.

While there are many cough medicines out there, most use the same four ingredients and despite the length of time they have been in use, there has been very little research done as to just how effective they are. Scientists have been recently looking to rectify this by combing through the past data, as well as conducting more sophisticated trials on the available options.

Their results come as a surprise to us and many of our co-workers in the health care field. The ingredient that seems to be the most effective is dextromethorphan (the DM frequently found within the name of many of the leading brands, such as Benylin DM and Robitussin DM) which is good news since it is by far the most common ingredient in the masses of cough syrups found on pharmacy shelves.

The antihistamine diphenhydramine (the ingredient found originally in the allergy tablet known as Benadryl) also seems to work very well and comes with the added benefit/drawback of being sedating.

Menthol, as well, seems to have a mild effect on cough sensitivity and is found in many lozenges as well as a number of syrups (such as Buckleys).

None of this is overly-surprising as it validates what many of our patients have been reporting for years. There was one result, however, that has caused us to rethink recommendations.

Codeine has long been touted as being a more effective suppressant than any of these other options but the evidence does not seem to support this whatsoever. In fact, codeine seems to have no impact on coughing although its sedative properties may help you sleep better regardless.

When this information is combined with the fact that codeine needs to be processed by the body in order to work and that people vary greatly in their ability to do so making the chemical deadly in a few unsuspecting patients, it is really hard to justify its use anymore.

For more information about this or any other health-related questions, contact the pharmacists at Gordon Pharmasave, Your Health and Wellness Destination. Also check the website at www.gordon-pharmasave.com/ and the Facebook page at www.facebook.com/GordonPharmasave/?fref=ts

Related Stories

No related stories.

Share

    Comments (0)

  1. No Comments.

Leave a Comment

By submitting this form, I consent that my name (and email, if provided) will be published on kincardinerecord.com as part of this story.


Banner Ad
Banner Ad